My News: TOP - Autos Intimate goods Chairs Underwear Ladies handbag Bracelets Sportswear Top auto-moto furniture Dating Boots FDA Approved Pharmacy Boats Necklace Yachts Medical tests Suits Medicine news Building materials Top casino Rington ya.by Tunings Sale Auto Chronometer Blog Search the Web Cases Mobiles Cigarettes Cars auto-moto Ear rings Cigarette Green Card Information
uncommonplace
 

    Follow me

     Civil right? Wrong question.
    Filed under: — David @ 5:16 pm

    I have heard and read many times the idea that same-sex marriage should be allowed because marriage is a civil right. The problem with this claim is that it very conveniently ignores the opposing argument, which is that the real issue is the definition of marriage. It makes no sense to discuss whether marriage is a civil right until we agree on how marriage is defined.

    So I’m actually undecided on whether marriage qualifies as a civil right, but I’m not very concerned about the question because I think it’s irrelevant, or at best premature.

    Out of curiosity, I have been searching the net for explanations of why marriage should be considered a civil right, looking at blog posts, articles, and court cases. In nearly all instances, people simply repeat the assertion that marriage is a civil right, without any kind of justification.

    The closest thing I’ve found so far is traced back to a 1942 decision in the case of Skinner v. Oaklahoma in which it was declared that sterilization should not be allowed as a punishment for crimes.

    We are dealing here with legislation which involves one of the basic civil rights of man. Marriage and procreation are fundamental to the very existence and survival of the race.

    This decision was referenced by the Goodridge v. Department of Public Health case in which the Massachusetts state supreme court declared that same-sex marriage should be allowed. (The other Massachusetts case cited on this subject is that of Milford v. Worcester, but the text of that decision doesn’t seem to be easily available online.)

    Finally, an explanation for this civil right idea. But I don’t buy it. Why not? For an explanation, I’ll use the words of the Hawaii state supreme court, in a case which is actually mentioned by the Massachusetts court, even though as far as I can tell it argues against their interpretation of Skinner v. Oaklahoma.

    Whether the [US Supreme] court viewed marriage and procreation as a single indivisible right, the least that can be said is that it was obviously contemplating unions between men and women when it ruled that the right to marry was fundamental.

    That was my reaction exactly. To use Skinner v. Oaklahoma to support same-sex marriage discards the entire context and severely manipulates the original meaning.

    So I’m still looking for an explanation… but still, only out of curiosity. I still believe that the definition of marriage is the real issue, and I firmly believe that gender, as a fundamental characteristic of the human race, is and should be a vital part of that definition.

     Nonplussed
    Filed under: — David @ 9:35 am

    The iTunes Store is now 100% “iTunes Plus”, which is their higher-quality, no-copy-protection format. Supposedly you can upgrade past purchases to iTunes Plus, but this is not entirely true.

    Just some quick statistics:

    Purchased albums in my iTunes library: 33
    Albums that the iTunes Store will let me upgrade to iTunes Plus: 13
    Albums that I can’t upgrade but are still in the iTunes Store: 8
    Albums I bought that are now missing from the iTunes Store: 12

    Surprisingly, the missing albums include the soundtracks to the first two Harry Potter films, The Fellowship of the Ring, and The Triplets of Belleville.


    This is my personal blog. The views expressed on these pages are mine alone and not those of my employer.

    Powered by WordPress

    Shareware Icons Games
    Topic - News Blogs: Bracelets auto-moto Chairs Blog Search the Web Top auto-moto Boats Autos Cases Intimate goods Necklace Trousers Underwear Top casino Sale Auto Building materials Evening dress Yachts Tunings Medicine news furniture Rington Replica Rolex Mobiles Rolex Replica Boots Ear rings Fashions Green Card Information ya.by Balans Cigarettes Medical tests Sport Betting Cars